A HUGE development may have just ended Labour’s plan to ban conversion practices

Dr Hilary Cass

by Mike Judge, Evangelical Times

This is a big moment, and a huge development, in the debate surrounding whether or not to criminalise so-called conversion practices. The bill which could criminalise parents and pastors having honest conversations about gender and sexuality may have just been – if not blown out of the water – certainly dealt a heavy blow. One of its biggest supporters has switched sides and is now deeply concerned about the bill’s implications.

Dr Hilary Cass has told the parliamentary committee scrutinising the legislation that she cannot support it in its present form. This is particularly significant because, when the draft bill was published in June, the government quoted Cass welcoming its clearer definitions and saying ministers had recognised the need for healthcare professionals to work without fear of litigation. Now, having examined the detail, she has withdrawn that support.

It’s also significant because of who Dr Hilary Cass is. She was responsible for the Cass Review which exposed serious failings in the NHS’s approach to children questioning their gender, challenged the uncritical acceptance of gender ideology in medicine, and called for a more cautious, evidence-based approach to treating young people. Her credibility in this debate is therefore considerable.

Cass explained that her original comments in support of the bill were made before she had properly seen the detailed wording. She told the committee that the text had been sent shortly before the government wanted a press statement signed off. She concluded that it was “nowhere near tight enough to avoid unintended consequences”.

Her concerns are substantial. Clinicians could face complaints for conducting careful, exploratory work with young people. Parents, too, could find themselves exposed to the law for declining to use a child’s requested pronouns or refusing to fund breast binders or hormones. Cass acknowledged that this might not be the government’s intention, but warned that the wording could nevertheless create that risk. She also said the legislation could discourage people from speaking up about failings in healthcare.

These are not the warnings of an eccentric fringe campaigner. Cass is a respected paediatrician whose work has had a profound influence on the debate about gender medicine. Government assurances about good intentions cannot substitute for precise legislation.

Read here