Oxford Union debate “ This house believes that the Church of England’s days are numbered”. The Noes won

November 19 2026

Proposing the motion:

Thomas Tadesse, a member of the Ethiopian Orthodox Church, a second year PPE student at St Peter’s College.

He made the case that the Church exists “to bring souls to God”. But the C of E in trying to appeal to as many as possible has lost almost everyone.

He personally was baptized in a church that is now redundant. Since 1969 2000 churches have been closed, the greatest reduction since the 16th century. Attendance at Church of England Churches is 590,000 on a Sunday, 1% of the population.

While the 4600 Church schools with a million pupils have provided a good civic service in educating 15 million people over time, less than 10% of children in church schools attend church. Parents might attend church for 6 months or so to secure a place in a church school for their child, once they are admitted they attend church no longer.

The clergy are called to be shepherds who know their flock, but 71% of them have to look after more than one parish. It is not really possible to shepherd a flock which you only visit once a month.

In Ethiopia persecution grew the church. The C of E clings to its privileges such as the 26 bishops in the House of Lords and has shrunk.

Without bringing souls to Christ, its days are numbered

Opposing the motion was Dr Mark Tanner, the Bishop of Durham.

He began by noting that what is highlighted about the CofE does not reflect the day to day life of the church. Being a bishop he sees its imperfections and seeks to address them.

He gave his life to Christ at the age of 8, giving him meaning and purpose in life and a community to belong to.

He addressed possible approaches the proposers of the motion might adopt. He agreed that the days of the church are numbered as all our days are numbered, but the church will continue till the Lord returns.

The Church of England at its heart is not the bishops in the House of Lords but the 125000 parishes, the 6000 chaplaincies and the 4500 Church schools. It is predominantly local. No one has been brought to Jesus as Lord by a diocese, but they do where people meet Christ at the local level. Through the parish the Church of England is deeply woven into the fabric of society.

It is leading the country in the implementation of safeguarding. 800,000 safeguarding courses have been completed and it is the most rigorous trainer in the field.

Project Spire on reparations for slavery has given rise to the most prophetic current statements on slavery which is more of a problem today than it was in the past.

The Church of England will always be focused around local communities changing lives.

Brought up as a Baptist, when he was studying maths as an Oxford undergraduate he attended St Aldates and learnt that Anglicans do not always agree with each other, since God is bigger than any of us.

He reminds vicars that he institutes to parishes that they are not chaplains to their congregation but are the ‘God-man or -woman’ in their community.

95% of the churches are involved in their communities through food banks and most the work of the churches is not visible.

He quoted John Keble’s insistence that “If the Church of England were to fail, it would be found in my parish.”

He concluded that even if the days of the Church of England are numbered, he would “continue to serve my Lord”.

The second speaker for the proposition was the Most Revd Foley Beach, former chairman of GAFCON and former Archbishop of the Anglican Church of North America.

He recalled a conversation with Archbishop Justin Welby, when he was in office, and he was raising questions about the Church of England. Archbishop Welby challenged him about what right he had to raise his questions and he replied that he had no right except as a brother in Christ.

He agreed that for all of us our days are numbered, but that the days of the Church of England are truly numbered for three reasons.

The first is that it is losing its role as the Church OF England.  37% of the population, 22 million people have no religion. 1 million identify as CofE. 4 million are Muslim and 6 million are Roman Catholic.  The CofE forms 20% of the Christians in England.  Surveys show some want the church to be there for weddings and funerals even if they don’t attend. They want the church to be there, but with their children and grandchildren?

Secondly the survival of the institution with its church buildings, dioceses and cathedrals must not be confused with the thriving of the church. The church exists to worship God, to teach the faith and convey the goodness of Jesus. The deeper question is what will exist, a vibrant Christian church? No.

He sadly recalled a conversation with an English bishop in 2016 after a meeting of Primates at Canterbury who said that he would never be told what to think, believe and do by black African bishops. He was appalled by the racism and arrogance that he would not even listen to others.

The institution surviving is not the same as the church thriving.

Third,  Canterbury is no longer the centre of world Anglicanism. The daughter churches of the Church of England have grown up. Anglicanism is most vibrant in the Global South. Their leaders lead churches of vibrant active Christians and no longer look to Canterbury. They are now sending missionary bishops to England. The demographic centre is away from England

God has renewed the church before, through the Wesleys, Whitefield and the Oxford Movement. But looking at the current trajectory it is difficult to deny its days are numbered. We lament its decline but are indebted to it for its liturgy, music and scholarship.  

The British Empire has gone but Britain has not

Christendom has gone but Christianity has not

Canterbury as the centre of Anglicanism is passing away but gospel of Jesus and growth of the true church continues.

Seconding for the opposition, Professor Grace Davie, author of ‘Religion in Britain’, argued that all institutions are in decline and losing respect. She noted that Church of England was like British army – “moving from conscription to choice”.  An advantage of being a weak state church was that it advocates for space for religion. The parish is still a key building block of society and a symbol of togetherness and inclusivity.

Richard Scorer, the author of Betrayed : the English Catholic Church and the Sex Abuse Crisis spoke of the stark reality of decline. (He was a replacement for Ms Jayne Ozanne who refused to share a platform with Bishop Foley Beach at what Harold Macmillan called ‘The Last Bastion of Free Speech in the Western World” ). It cannot be Church of England. What does it believe? What is the brand? It is not sustainable to have endless arguments eg about marriage. Establishment is a comfort blanket. It has a State subsidy like British Leyland. There is an arrogance in the senior leadership. There have been safeguarding failures  and it has no moral authority.

Lee Gatiss, the Director of the Church Society agreed that there were bad apples and toxic subcultures which have damaged credibility. The graphs are down. Debates about doctrine are exhausting. But history has examples of predictions of institutions disappearing and of the C of E as well, but these have not been fulfilled. This is realism but not fatalism. We are not speaking about the Titanic but about Apollo 13. The Reformers were burned but C of E rose again. In the 1800s John Henry Newman preceded revival. He closed with a call to the audience to repent and believe!

There were strong statements from the floor – for and against motion.

Closing for the opposition The Rev Dr Sam Wells vicar of St Martin-in-the-Fields spoke of Jesus as the bridge between heaven and earth. The Church is called to join him, not as a powerful institution ( Goliath) but in weakness and humility challenging injustice at the local level. The Church’s days seeing itself as Goliath are numbered but it can still be David!

Bishop Andy Lines, the Bishop of the Anglican Network in Europe closing for the proposers of the motion, argued that the C of E was now an outdated chaplain to a society which no longer believes. Statistics show inexorable decline – C of E attendance is only 20% of all churchgoers in England . New forms of Anglicanism not linked to Canterbury are growing. Faithful believers in C of E have to balance the usefulness of access to funds and buildings with attempts to distance themselves from a compromised institution and leadership who are increasingly under pressure from government. Remember Jesus is Lord and will build his church!

Report compiled from the notes of Revd Andrew Symes, former director of Anglican Mainstream and Canon Dr Chris Sugden, chairman of Anglican Mainstream.