Synod Day 2: Does it matter where God dwells?

Westminster Abbey High Altar Wiki

from Anglican Futures

Speaking off-the-cuff is always a challenge. A prepared speech offers the opportunity to consider each word and the way it might land with the audience. The Archbishop of York even revealed today that his speeches are sometimes be written by others. But when an Archbishop speaks extemporally they offer a deeper insight into their inner voice and their own theological understanding.

On Wednesday, the Archbishop of Canterbury responded to the comments made after her Loyal Address with these words:

“You mentioned the King’s Coronation, I was very struck, that at his Coronation, sitting in the position I did, that first and foremost His Majesty faced the altar – he faced God. A reminder that as he knelt, he knelt before the King of Kings, the Lord of Lords, as a child beloved of God, just as you and I do.”

This, like so much of what the Archbishop of Canterbury commends, is a blend of truth and folk religion.

First, there is the issue of describing the ‘table’ as an ‘altar’. While this is common practice in Roman Catholicism, one would search in vain to find the table found in a church descibed as an ‘altar’ in the Book of Common Prayer, the Thirty-Nine Articles or the relevant Canons of the Church of England.

An altar is a place of sacrifice – but the table is where we eat and drink in remembrance of Christ’s sacrifice. In the words of the BCP, Christ suffered, “for our redemption; who made there (by his one oblation of himself once offered) a full, perfect, and sufficient sacrifice, oblation, and satisfaction, for the sins of the whole world,”. As the writer to the Hebrews makes clear in chapter 13 – it is Christ who is both our sacrifice and our altar, and we come to Him. The presence of a table, rather than an altar, reminds us that we are invited to partake, “of his most blessed Body and Blood,” but that the sacrifice is complete.

Second, is the suggestion that, “.. first and foremost His Majesty faced the altar – he faced God.”

Read here