Those Home Office pamphlets lay bare Labour’s failed thinking on immigration

by Miriam Cates, Conservative Home

I imagine there were some tense moments for the Number 10 press team last week after the leak of a Home Office pamphlet that implores asylum seekers not to rape women and girls.

The government can no longer pretend that British residents living near camps, hotels and HMOs housing illegal migrants are ‘safe’. The very existence of the document proves that authorities know that some men from some countries and cultures simply have no understanding of women’s rights or sexual consent.

To admit that some cultures are inferior to others has long been a taboo on the Left. Liberals are more than happy to criticise the behaviour of individuals – whether that is calling out ‘misogyny’ or ‘racism’ – but can’t, or won’t, draw the link between cultural norms and individual actions. Over the last few months, the Guardian newspaper has printed a number of informative pieces about the appalling treatment of women and girls in Afghanistan, where the Taliban continues its assault on women’s rights since the withdrawal of US and UK troops in 2021. In Afghanistan, there is no longer a minimum age of marriage. Girls have no choice over who or when they marry, and there is no such thing as marital rape, which means that there is no legal concept of sexual consent.

Of course not every man in Afghanistan thinks it is acceptable to force sex on a woman – just as not every man in Britain thinks such acts are unacceptable. But it is sensible to assume that many of the young men from Afghanistan who arrive in Britain on small boats or in the back of a lorry do not see women as equal human beings. This assumption is borne out in court proceedings. At the trial last year of Sadeq Nikzad, a 29-year-old Afghan asylum seeker convicted of raping a 15-year-old girl in Falkirk, Scotland, Nikzad’s lawyer argued in mitigation that her client had not been educated about the significant “cultural” differences between the UK and Afghanistan, where child marriage (i.e. rape) is prevalent.

The Prime Minister and many Labour MPs defend the Home Office pamphlet by arguing that it is important to inform recent arrivals of the law of the land. But that is to trivialise the nature of the offences being described: it’s easy enough to adhere to a new country’s regulations on speed limits or drink driving tolerances. But, just as a British person arriving in Somalia will not suddenly start believing that Female Genital Mutilation is an important traditional practice, neither will all Somalians give up their determination to cut their daughters just because a nine-page government document informs them it’s against UK law.

Read here